The keto coconut panna cotta is a melt in your mouth, velvety smooth wobbly dessert that’s crazy easy to make! (even though it looks really fancy!) This recipe is made with coconut milk and naturally sweetened with stevia, so it’s dairy-free and sugar-free and a super healthy dessert!
Panna cotta are the dessert of choice when chefs try to show off. Appearing not only as a recurrent theme in reality TV cooking shows, they are also often seen in many starred hotel dessert buffets, and solo in upscale restaurant menus – at a high price tag. All of which makes you think that panna cottas are a really complex recipe. I used to believe so too. But you are in for a surprise.
Part of the reason why Italian panna cotta is always showing up in high end settings is the easy customization: Panna cotta can be dressed up in many ways, creating unique and sophisticated presentations. You can serve your keto panna cotta in glasses with toppings – or bottoms – or unmolded, plated and decorated.
You can go wild with the options, looking for keto or low-carb versions of shaved or melted chocolate, citrus peels or zest, thinly sliced fruit, small berries, jam or compote, or juice or alcoholic reductions, sugar-free liqueurs, custard… anything goes, and almost everything will taste and look incredible.
The different thing about this keto coconut panna cotta recipe? Panna cotta are traditionally made with dairy cream, and the fancy sounding name literally means “cooked cream” in Italian. But I had an open can of coconut milk – from my many pandan cake experiments – and thought, you know what… Why not try coconut milk instead of dairy cream panna cotta? It worked. The texture is as creamy and wobbly as its cow’s milk equivalent, and the delicate coconut taste is yum!
How to make keto panna cotta
Blooming, or hydrating the gelatin before adding the hot liquid is essential to avoid lumps, and achieve a smooth and silky keto panna cotta. Put 50 grams of water in a bowl and add the 2 teaspoons of powder gelatin on top, give it a quick stir with a fork, and let the gelatin rest for a while to bloom.
Heat up the the coconut milk in a saucepan on medium heat, or in a jar/mug in the microwave, with the (optional) vanilla extract and stevia – I gave a couple of squirts from the bottle, and tried for sweetness. Your keto panna cotta should not be overly sweet, so you can really taste the delicate coconut milk.
After the mixture is really hot but before boiling, you can add it to the bloomed gelatin. Mix it very well, until the gelatin is completely dissolved.
How to make a quick sugar-free strawberry jam
Simmer the strawberries and water in a saucepan until softened, them crush them out with a fork or potato masher.
Remove from heat, and when it stops bubbling taste it for sweetness, and adjust to your liking by adding drops of stevia.
We’re taking a shortcut here: no need for blooming the gelatin, if you are quick. If you aren’t, that’s OK. You won’t be able to tell a small gelatin lump from the strawberry bits, anyway. Just sprinkle the gelatin evenly around the top of the sugar-free strawberry sauce and immediately mix it well with a fork. Put the mixture in your chosen serving glasses and take them to the fridge to set.
I chose to serve these dairy-free panna cotta straight out of cocktail glasses, with the strawberry base set on the bottom of the glass. If you don’t mind waiting longer (around 6 hours or overnight) you can serve them unmolded: Run a sharp knife around the top edge, dip the container into hot water for a couple of seconds only to loosen the keto panna cotta and turn it onto the serving plate.
Be careful with the timing when dipping your keto panna cotta in hot water: there’s a fine line between just long enough to get the panna cotta unstuck OR to melt it away and have it flop out, smashed onto the plate like a melted pancake. It happened 😞 Still delicious, though!
Copyright Pris Frank for LikeHotKeto. Please DO NOT SCREENSHOT OR COPY/PASTE recipes to social media or websites. We’d LOVE for you to share a link to this recipe instead 🙂 Try the easy sharing buttons below!
This was so delicious, love the strawberry and coconut flavors!!
Thank you Noelle 🙂
Love this panacotta recipe! The flavors are wonderful and it’s so easy too. I’ll definitely be making again!
I’m so glad you liked it Kim!
Panacottas look so good! Can’t wait to try these with friends.
Love your recipe with coconut milk and have to try it soon! Im currently in Italy on holiday, so perfect recipe to bookmark!
This Recipe is absolutely delicious. The flavors really come together. We love the strawberry and coconut combination. I made this with my family this past weekend and it was a hit with everyone. This was the first time we ever made Pana cotta. Adding it to our list to make again!
Thank you Tania! Enjoy Italy and try an original panna cotta while in there! 🙂
I’m sure you and your friends love these keto panna cottas, Katie!
I’m so glad you liked, Cindy!